Skip to main content
2:00 pm
good people. human progress never rolls in on the wheels of inevitability. it comes through the tireless efforts of men willing to be co-workers with god and without this hard work time itself becomes an ally of the forces of stagnation. we must use time creatively in the knowledge that the time is always ripe to do the right thing. thanks so much for watching. chris matthews and "hardball" is next. does gop mean guns over people? let's play "hardball." ♪ good evening.
2:01 pm
i'm chris matthews in washington. let me start tonight with this. this afternoon two men were wounded and yet another school shooting. this time in st. louis. today's shooting comes as the republican party is siding with the folks out there who want lots of semiautomatic fire power to fight this country's elected government. so has it become the guns over people party? republican u.s. senator rand paul of kentucky talks about the president usurping the constitution. republican texas congressman steve stockman talks about impeaching the president if he takes steps to upgrade gun safety by executive order. remember sharron angle, the nevada republican senate candidate talking openly about using second amendment remedies against public officials. people used to think she was alone out there, something of an oddity. what's becoming clear is in today's gop she's more typical than not. ed rendell was governor of pennsylvania, michael steele was chair of the republican party. gentlemen, thank you. president obama will announce his plans for gun safety tomorrow after hearing vice president biden's task force
2:02 pm
recommendations, but already criticism is mounting on the right. here is republican senator rand paul of kentucky. >> i'm against having a king. i think having a monarch is what we fought the american revolution over, and someone who wants to bypass the constitution, bypass congress, that's someone who wants to act like a king or a monarch. i've been opposed to executive orders even with republican presidents, but one that wants to infling on the second amendment we will fight tooth and nail, and i promise you there will be no rock left unturned as far as trying to stop him from usurping the constitution. >> okay. on the house side rand paul is not alone. u.s. congressman steve stockman of east texas hasn't ruled out impeachment after hearing the president may use executive orders for some gun safety measures. he released a statement saying in part, i will seek to thwart this action by any means necessary, including but not limited to eliminating funding for implementation, defunding the white house, and even filing
2:03 pm
articles of impeachment. the president's actions are not just an attack on the constitution, he says, and a violation of his sworn oath of office. they are a direct attack on americans that place all of us in danger. if the president is allowed to suspend constitutional rights on his own personal whims, our free republic has effectively ceased to exist. governor, these people talk as if haven't elected our government. they talk like it's a monarchy from england. this is the crazy talk here in this country. the government treated as a foreign institution, something way out somewhere controlled by not even americans, but by the enemies of america, and now they talk about guns that they need to have in hand in case they have to go to work dealing with that government basically with fire power. this language is brand new to me. it seems to me this used to be posse comitatus talk out in idaho. now it's become the normal lingua franca of the republican
2:04 pm
party. >> they don't have a clue what's in the 18 or 19 things the president is going to do by executive order. my belief is they're mostly about collection of data, not exactly frontal assault on the second amendment. so they should wait and see what they are before they start popping off. in terms of the major things, background checks for everybody, ending the high capacity magazines, assault weapons ban, those are things that still have to go before a congress for a vote. to tell you the truth, although it's a little scary to hear these people, i am also not displeased when i hear these wacko comments because it drives more and more people who are on the fence over to our side saying, look, these guys are nuts. weaver got to have sensible gun laws, and we do have to have sensible gun laws. let me tell you for every representative stockman, there's representative dent and fitzpatrick and gerlach who -- >> explain that because you know that suburban politics where you have republicans representing moderate political communities,
2:05 pm
and how will they react. >> not just philadelphia, but in st. louis, chicago, cleveland, and places like that, and those republicans are going to face a real tough decision. they stay with the nra and they endanger their re-election because in those districts, 70%, 880% of the people want these sensible measures. they want background checks for everyone, no exceptions. they want high capacity magazines band. they want assault rifles banned. it's going to be a real test all over this country. >> michael steele is here. michael, you're a reasonable guy obviously. let's look at these numbers. "the washington post" numbers on gun show background checks, 88% support. this is a new "washington post" poll here. overwhelmingly support these. 88% support gun show background checks which we don't have really today. 76%, three-quarters approve the gun checks when buying ammo. 71% say yes to a federal gun database. that's important.
2:06 pm
65% support a ban on high capacity magazines, and 58% support a ban on assault weapons. it gets tougher about the assault weapon ban and i think that's why harry reid, the head of the democratic party in the senate, is nervous about submitting it to the congress because he figures it won't pass the house. >> two points. one, i think the poll -- and the irony here is a lot of the stuff you just showed the nra was behind. they didn't have a problem with -- >> that's right. >> -- the gun show checks -- >> in the days of yesteryear. >> in the days of yesteryear and i think they need to get back to that. >> you know the politics. why this they gone to this rejecti rejectionist? >> i'll be the washington cynic and the fact is it's fund raising and membership. and you look -- >> is it gun sales? >> absolutely gun sales, am mission, from ammunition to guns. take that off the table. you still have the slaughter of 20 innocents here. that's what is driving the american people. that's the focus of our community right now is if this can happen in newtown,
2:07 pm
massachusetts, it's certainly happens in chicago -- >> respond to what the governor said about the suburban governors who aren't right wingers. if you were still party chair, what language would you -- how would you position your party on guns? >> i would position it where the party has always been working towards common sense solutions that, number one, enforce those currently on the book. there are good enforceable laws on the book. two, let's look at where the loopholes are, if that's the gun shows, if that's, you know, with having a database that's incomplete, let's fix those things because, again, that's where the nra has been. >> governor, you made the point that a lot of the things being talked about, the president will come out with tomorrow. we don't know for sure but we got a pretty good line with "the new york times" today. look at these. i don't think these are at all authoritarian as you pointed out. a tougher prosecution of people who lie on their background checks. why would the nra be for people lying on their background checks? >> she should be supportive of that. >> and this other one, research
2:08 pm
on gun violence. i don't know what research scares anybody. this one limits on guns imported from overseas. i mean, is that something the president can do by executive order? i don't know. >> i'm not sure either. >> what about this -- this is a good one. sharing of mental health records. this is an aclu question. this comes from the other end politically, right, michael? >> absolutely right. >> you might find people on what we call the political left -- >> who have a problem. >> we don't want the word out with everybody with an emotional -- every time you go to a psychiatrist and you have a problem, do you really want that to be -- do you want to be put on a list? >> chris -- >> for purposes of checking to see whether you're gun eligible, that becomes an issue. >> are these only court-ordered situations, governor? >> yeah. >> when they say put a database -- onch people with court ordered action. >> the one thing that the nra has said other than the guns in schools, the one thing they have said they're for is tightening up the mental health reporting. so this is one where then ra is even for it. how is that an assault on
2:09 pm
anything? >> let's try to get that the mind of some of these yahoos talking like this guy. yag ser out there saying he's -- this is a so-called apology. let's look at this. you might recall this is last week, this kind of disturbing guy came out and talked about tactical response, about shooting people in response to white house action on guns. well, now he's sort of recanting. here is a bit of his semiautomatic apology. >> i said some pretty volatile stuff, which i apologize for. i do not in any way advocate the overthrowing of the united states government nor do i condone any violent actions towards any elected officials. it's not time to shoot anybody. it is -- what it is time to do is to organize politically, contact our elected officials, and help steer the ship the direction that we want it to go. >> well, as my old boss tip
2:10 pm
o'neill would say, timing is everything. and this guy the term timing refers to when you begin firing. he says there's still time to talk to these people before -- it's not time to shoot anybody. maybe that's just his way of speaking, gsk, but to most people it sounds like english and it sounds like this guy might be fire when ready or whatever when it's appropriate. firing at government officials. >> right. we don't need to do it right now, but if things get worse, we have to do it. look, all those guys do is drive ordinary, responsible people to the conclusion that we've got to do something and we've got to do it now. >> well, and i agree -- >> again, i hate to put you back in your pocket, in the republican party, but will they allow themselves to be positioned by the press or by their numbers or by their crazy people into being the party as i said, the party of guns over people? >> i don't think so, and i don't think that any self-respecting republican is going to take on the moniker of guns over people. >> how about the unself-respecting like steve stockton -- >> i do know this, chris.
2:11 pm
i appreciate both sides of this argument, which is why it's timely. let's just put it -- >> you appreciate the argument you need a gun to protect yourself from the government? >> i do appreciate that to a certain extent, sure. i understand where it comes from, and so that's a lot of this conversation has now gotten off track. i think the party has an opportunity working with their constituent groups out there to get it back on track so as that gentleman just said, what our issues are they can be addressed in due course. and right now a lot of people feel this is not where this is going to go. see where the president comes out tomorrow with his list and that's when the conversation really begins. >> let's make a prediction. governor rendell, will president obama come out for an assault weapons ban as part of his package tomorrow? >> yes. >> will he? >> yes. you have got to go big, and, look, even if the assault weapons ban goes down, he can still get the ban on high capacity magazines and 100% background checks. those are tremendous victories. i'm not sure the assault weapons
2:12 pm
ban will go down. everyone is acting like it's dead in the water and harry reid, hey, let's man up and try to do the right thing. we may surprise ourselves. >> don't be a with us, right? >> right. don't be a wuss. >> i think they -- my thought, you can't have reaction to what happened up in connecticut without dealing with the weapon used, the bush master. >> absolutely. >> unless that's on your hit list of weapons you want to keep from the crazy the at least. >> and, again, i think you're right there. that's going to be part of where the conversation is going to go from here on out. >> you have to go after the weapon used in the case. thank you governor rendell and michael steele. president obama's next battle with congress may have gotten a bit easier. chuck schumer, a leader in the senate, has given his stamp of approval for chuck hagel as the sex be secretary of defense. haguels's nomination is another example we think here at "hardball" of obama's newfound fighting spirit and we like it, of course. from the debt careering to the nra, to the neocons.
2:13 pm
the president is sticking it to his opponents and he's winning. and the house of representatives is voting on a relief package for the victims of superstorm sandy. will republicans stand up to help those hit by the form. let me finish with a republican party that's beginning to sound and look like a pack of moon shiners. they don't like those revenuers. this is "hardball," the place for politics. are you flo? yes. is this the thing you gave my husband? well, yeah, yes. the "name your price" tool. you tell us the price you want to pay, and we give you a range of options to choose from. careful, though -- that kind of power can go to your head. that explains a lot. yo, buddy! i got this. gimme one, gimme one, gimme one! the power of the "name your price" tool. only from progressive.
2:14 pm
relief package for the victims next monday president obama will be sworn into office for his second presidential term, and we continue our look back at great inaugural moments. here is the first president who was born in the 20th century, john f. kennedy. >> let the word go forth from this time and place to friend and foe alike, that the torch has been passed to a new generation of americans born in this century, tempered by war h disciplined by a hard and bitter
2:15 pm
feast, proud of our ancient heritage, and unwilling to witness or permit the small undoing of those human rights to which this nation has always been committed and to which we are committed today at home and around the world. >> wow. later in that speech jfk said another of his most famous lines, ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country. it's a line he paraphrased from george stmplt john, the head master at his prep school. i learned that nugget while researching for my book, "jack kennedy, elusive hero." does that make a difference? search "cost of financial advisors" i learned that nugget while researching for my book, "jack kennedy, elusive hero." ow much . spoiler alert: it's low.
2:16 pm
really? yes, really. e-trade offers investment advice and guidance from dedicated, professional financial consultants. it's guidance on your terms, not ours. that's how our system works. e-trade. less for us. more for you. to help protect your eye health as you age... would you take it? well, there is. [ male announcer ] it's called ocuvite. a vitamin totally dedicated to your eyes, from the eye care experts at bausch + lomb. as you age, eyes can lose vital nutrients. ocuvite helps replenish key eye nutrients. ocuvite has a unique formula not found in your multivitamin to help protect your eye health. now that's a pill worth taking. [ male announcer ] ocuvite. help protect your eye health.
2:17 pm
welcome back to "hardball." today president obama got an important buy-in you might say for his defense secretary nominee. chuck hagel from the powerful
2:18 pm
new york senator chuck schumer. this morning schumer released a statement that reads in part, based on several key assurances provided by senator hagel, i am currently prepared to vote for his confirmation. i encourage my senate colleagues who have shared my previous concerns to also support him. well, this coupled with senator barbara boxer's vote of support yesterday has made his path for conformation look a lot easier. joining me is "the huffington post's" sam stein and "time" magazine magazine's. i thought schumer would take more time. got it on the record, maybe got a little more pro hawkish than he was to start with the interview but he got what he needed. i was impressed at the speed with which this is being done. your thoughts? >> i'm sort of with you on the one hand. it looked like schumer had legitimate concerns about what hagel's positions were with respect to iran and israel. then again, i thought about what was behind the act?
2:19 pm
it" the end it was a democratic president appointing a cabinet member. it didn't shock me that schumer was on board. i was surprised by the speed. but it looks like it's shaping up for a relatively more comfortable confirmation battle for chuck hagel. >> michael, what i think it's not abouted a tud. i don't know where cardin is going to go. i don't know where a lot of people from big states, jewish communities are more sensitive to the language he's used in the past, but it seems to me that what will beat him now is evidence. not argument. it comes out that he's used bad language, ethnic language, if he said things or just showed an attitude publicly in a way that can be verified, he's still got problems if that happens. >> sure, anything can happen. hagel talks expansively. he's a little like biden. to his credit and i think something obama likes about him, he's not a totally programmed -- >> biden had a lot to do with pushing this, didn't he? >> i think that's a key thing to
2:20 pm
understand. those two guys are really close. as far as the speed of it, i think they drew a lesson from what happened to susan rice. she hung out there twisting on the vine. they didn't marshall the forces. she didn't have a lot of public defenders. this is the opposite of that. this is an organized, quick campaign. they want to batten down the hatches and basically make him safe for people to vote for and move forward with it and get the controversy behind them. >> let's talk about another big event that happened this week, another shoe that dropped, general powell this sunday. let's look at general powell on our own "meet the press" and the way he went at this very directly. he was very pointed here in the middle of what we're going snow you, very pointed for a politician to talk with this kind of exquisiteness. let's listen. >> a lot of my friends in the community who are of a more rightist persuasion, ones who have been hawking -- the hawks. >> well, the hawk, do you think they're out of line in their criticism? >> no, they're fair criticisms. they can make all the criticisms
2:21 pm
they want. when they go over the edge and say because chuck said jewish lobby, he's anti-semitic, that's disgraceful. we shouldn't have that kind of language in our dialogue baugh they're fully entitled to their views. i didn't think they would go away and never be heard from again. they have to remember one thing, it's president obama and not president mccain and not president romney. they lost two elections. the american people have made it clear they're not particularly interested in finding new con flibts to get into. >> that's where i think this might be headed to those nuances down the road. when you get in the hearing room with the lights on and cameras there, sam, and a lot of heat with maybe some adversarial questions from i don't know who is going to be -- cornyn of texas, people like that, my take a shot at this guy, they'll be under pressure. if there's language about jewish lobby, we'll give you a bye on that, that could mean a particular thing rather than the general pro-israeli lobby you're talking about or whatever, but you start getting into language, the former secretary of state, the general, saying you can't
2:22 pm
accuse a guy of being anti-semitic because he uses a term of art you don't like. you can't jump to the conclusion he's got an ethnic problem. my sense is these hearings are going to be very tough for hagel already. >> it could be, but on the other hand, remember, he was out there as a rumored nominee for a couple weeks in which his opponents working in the dark mainly were combing through his entire record looking for that very moment that you're referencing. they turned up the jewish lobby quote. they turned up some other stuff about negotiations with iran. they turned up some uncomfortable votes about sanctions and that's largely seemed to do little to actually slow down the nomination or the confirm aths process. i think in the end there could be something that trips it up, but i think we're also understating the war weariness of this country. what hagel represents for a lot of people, a lot of lawmakers is, well, is a real turn of the page in terms of how we conceive of using armed forces overseas. i think a lot more people are on his side of that philosophical 150id of the debate -- >> you're so smart.
2:23 pm
that's the sweeping change, the 180 from where we were. here is senator bob corker raising an issue that's very subjective. he's a reasonable republican from tennessee. he's talking about hagel's suitability to be defense secretary. listen to the kind ever words he uses here. >> i think another thing, george, that's going to come up is just his overall temperament, and is he suited to the run a department or a big agency or a big entity like the pentagon. >> well, there you go. this is the kind of thing that will drive hagel and i don't know the guy, i met him a few times, crazy. somebody will say to him in the middle of a hearing, i hear you're always on the $sif. you have a defensive personality. then you depp fend yourself anz you're being defensive. i hear you have a bad temper. what do you mean i have a bad temper? this is getting rough because all politicians have bad temps. >> i think in a hearing when people are looking -- >> not all. >> it's a low bar, it's not that hard to maintain -- >> what do you do when a guy
2:24 pm
says i hear you yell at people in the office? >> maybe you say, look, i'm tough and demanding of my employees but i expect results and if somebody's ego is bruised, i apologize but this is a big boy business. i think i would make the point, make he won't, that maybe what do you think, 95, 98, 10 members of the u.s. senator have a similar rap. >> they don't have a nuclear button. >> that's right but, look, but hagel is not going to be freelancing starting wars. i don't think anyone is worried about that anyway. i just don't think that that's going to bring him down. it was interesting, corker wassen at this mating there are staffers who have come forward and contacted republicans. i think we may be seeing more planted stories. at the end of the day i think he's okay. he's gotten blessings from boxer and schumer on the issues democrats are worried about snp. >> we've done the personnel issue. probably get through, but, sam, one thing to you, you raise the larger question, the macro question, dove versus hawk. do the neocons, the hawks, feel they have an agenda which will not be met now in terms of
2:25 pm
getting more involved with syria, perhaps taking a faster line in terms of action or aligning ourselves with israel and taking action on iran? >> yes, that's the big concern, and i think that's what's driving a lot of this. we're sort of obsessed with the side show components which are did he say something offensive to an openly gay ambassador, was he using the wrong terminology with respect to the israel lobby? but the real concern from the hawks' advantage taj point is what does this mean with respect to the sanctions regime in iran? what does it mean with respect to the israel/palestine conflict in terms of support for israeli settlements? those are the main drivers of the opposition for hagel, and for them it's an existential concern in some respect because they believe obama extended a lot of parts of the bush foreign policy. they dornt want to see that end. >> the issue isn't hagel, it's the president. hagel is a lagging indicator -- >> i think it's a leading indicator. i think he's obama with a war record. >> exactly. >> i think he's the real obama. thank you, sam stein and i like
2:26 pm
it, of course. sam tine and michael crowley. although i think hagel is a notch to my left actually. up next, rush limbaugh has a crazy theory about why lib rools love the movie "lincoln." what else would be crazy from this guy? it's got to do with the civil war and some unfinished business. thank you, michael crowley. this is "hardball," the place for politics. here's what happened... i was talking to my best friend. i told her i wasn't feeling like myself... i had pain in my pelvic area... and bleeding that wasn't normal for me. she said i had to go to the doctor.
2:27 pm
turned out i had uterine cancer, a type of gynecologic cancer. i received treatment and we're confident i'll be fine. please listen to your body. if something doesn't feel right for two weeks or longer, see your doctor. get the inside knowledge about gynecologic cancers. knowing can make all the difference in the world. i love the fact that quicken loans provides va loans. quicken loans understood the details and guided me through every step of the process. i know wherever the military sends me, i can depend on quicken loans. wherever the military sends me, iimagine living your life withss less chronic low back pain.. imagine you with less pain. cymbalta can help. cymbalta is fda-approved to manage chronic musculoskeletal pain. one non-narcotic pill a day, every day, can help reduce this pain. tell your doctor right away if your mood worsens, you have unusual changes in mood or behavior or thoughts of suicide. antidepressants can increase these in children, teens, and
2:28 pm
young adults. cymbalta is not for children under 18. people taking maois, linezolid or thioridazine or with uncontrolled glaucoma should not take cymbalta. taking it with nsaid pain relievers, aspirin or blood thinners may increase bleeding risk. severe liver problems, some fatal, were reported. signs include abdominal pain and yellowing skin or eyes. tell your doctor about all your medicines, including those for migraine and while on cymbalta, call right away if you have high fever, confusion and stiff muscles or serious allergic skin reactions like blisters, peeling rash, hives, or mouth sores to address possible life-threatening conditions. talk about your alcohol use, liver disease and before you reduce or stop cymbalta. dizziness or fainting may occur upon standing. ask your doctor about cymbalta. imagine you with less pain. cymbalta can help. go to to learn about a free trial offer.
2:29 pm
back to "hardball." now to the "sideshow." remember the time mitt romney strapped his dog shamus in a kennel on the roof of his car for a 12-hour family road trip? it was back in the '80s bu dog lovers were disturbed by it. it looks like florida governor rick scott is having his shamus moment. in 2010 after getting his party's nomination for governor a new member of scott's family became part of his campaign, his recue labrador retriever.
2:30 pm
voters helped select the name nor the dog, there it is, reagan. as in the president. but where is reagan now? reporters from the tampa bay times couldn't get any straight answers from scott's aides and only got to the bottom of it when the governor stepped in. it turns out reagan the dog was too hyperactive upon arrival at the governor's mansion. he was not around long according to the tampa bay times. quote, scott said reagan never bit anyone but scared the living daylights out of people at the mansion. so the scots gave the dog back to his prior owner. isn't that sad? check out the resulting headline from the washington times. florida's first dog returned by governor scott. no wonner scott's people were reluctant to break the news themselves. take a look at this menu from a utah smoothie bar. drink prices according to the party affiliation. and the owner of the place isn't kidding. >> i'm very open about it, very public about it. i'm going to charge them a little bit more and i have liberals come in and pay the extra dollar surcharge, and
2:31 pm
actually all three liberals have been happy to pay it. we have a fiscal problem in this country. we've got to deal with it. or we don't have a country. so to kind of help make that point a little bit, i charge just a little bit more. >> three liberal customers, that's all. the owner says whatever he clents from his liberal surcharge, 3 bucks so far, go he is to republican causes like the heritage foundation. next, rush limbaugh has a theory about why so many on the left are fans of the movie "lincoln." >> why is bill clinton out there at the golden globes last night being brought on stage to thunderous standing ovations to talk about lincoln and what he did during -- what did lincoln do? as far as these people are concerned, he wiped out the south. but he didn't finish, so what the left is admitting today that they are doing is once -- trying to finish it off. lincoln did not fully finish.
2:32 pm
they're all focused on gods and guns in the south. they love both of them. and so the south has to be wiped out again. i'm telling you, essentially there is an all-out effort being made to marginalize conservatism. >> reminds me of radio rwanda in the bad old days. it's been far right republicans obviously doing all the civil war talk. they're the ones talking about the civil war, about nullification of federal laws and all the ses session petitions out there. before house republicans head off for their annual retreat this week, i think it's in williamsburg, the democratic congressional campaign committee offered up some suggestions for planned activities and classes. how to stop talking about legitimate rape and insulting women, science 101, creating task breaks and tax shelters for million air campaign donors and after that ppp poll showing how unpopular congress really is, there's how to increase our
2:33 pm
approval ratings. what root canals, traffic jams, cockroaches, and head lice are doing to us. and republicans are presumably doing wrong i guess. up next, the house of representatives will be voting tonight on a big aide package for the victims of hurricane sandy. but will republicans go along with it? especially from the south. you're watching "hardball," the place for politics. [ man ] ring ring... progresso this reduced sodium soup says it may help lower cholesterol, how does it work? you just have to eat it as part of your heart healthy diet.
2:34 pm
step 1. eat the soup. all those veggies and beans, that's what may help lower your cholesterol and -- well that's easy [ male announcer ] progresso. you gotta taste this soup.
2:35 pm
2:36 pm
i'm sue herera with your cnbc market wrap. the dounl gained 27 points. the s&p gained a point and the nasdaq slipped about 6 points partly because of the big story which continues to be apple which tumbled well below the
2:37 pm
$500 mark. the company is still anchored down by weaker than expected iphone 5 demand. facebook announced a new feature called a graph search that let's users combine phrasers to search for content. that's it from cnbc, we are first in business worldwide, and now back to chris and "hardball." welcome back to "hardball." when the year 2012 closed out without a house vote on aid for sandy victims up in the northeast, the outrage from both democrats and republicans who represent the region was overwhelming. let's listen. >> there's only one group to blame for the continued suffering of these innocent victims, the house majority and their speaker, john boehner. >> we cannot believe that this cruel knife in the back was
2:38 pm
delivered to our region. >> it is the most disgraceful action i have seen in this house in the 20 years i have been here. >> the fact is this dismissive attitude that was shown last night toward new york, new jersey, and connecticut typifies, i believe, a strain in the republican party. i can't imagine that type of indifference, that type of disregard, that cavalier attitude being shown to any other part of the country. >> well, now the house of representatives tonight has a second chance. on january 3rd the house passed a $9.7 billion bill that would help pay sandy victims' insurance claims by replenishing the national flood insurance program. today the house votes, actually tonight, on the big money, more than $50 billion in sandy aid. joining me is new york congressman michael grimm who rents areas in staten island. thank you for joining us tonight. let me show you an ad run back in 1964 by the republicans -- the democrats, rather, representing the opinion of the republican party voiced by barry
2:39 pm
goldwater. this was a very hot ad way before you were born. let's take a look at this. >> in a saturday evening post article dated august 31st, 1963, barry goldwater said, sometimes i think this country would be better off if we could just saw off the eastern seaboard and let it float out to sea. can a man who makes statements like this be expected to serve all the people justly and fairly? vote for president johnson on november 3rd. the stakes are too high for you to stay home. >> congressman grimm, is there an anti-new york attitude in the republican party nationally, anti-new york? >> i don't think so. i mean, there's always been a little bias against new york. i think that goes way back. there's no question. i've seen it and felt it. but i think what we have right now is just, you know, the deep-rooted concern overall that the country is spending money that it doesn't have and the need to be fiscally responsible,
2:40 pm
which i wholeheartedly agree with and i respect, it's cluster when things like this happen, natural disasters -- >> i didn't hear this during katri katrina. when the southerners were voting their own pocket boost, when the southern republicans were helping themselves out in what was really a tragedy as well as this one and it was very vivid, maybe more vivid in terms of national coverage than new york, i got to tell you, i didn't hear anybody talking about offsets. i heard them saying let's get the money to people like hailey bauer bor. >> i understand that but let's look at history. you were in a totally different political climate. all we've been talking about in the last two years is cutting revenue. it's more to do about where we are in time right now. we didn't have a deficit and debt crisis the way we do right now. let's be fair about the facts. we are in a debt crisis. however, when something like this happens, it's an exception to the rule. these people are hurting. they need the help of the federal government, and that's
2:41 pm
what we're going to deliver today. the bottom line is we're going to move forward and get this done. >> you know, i have been blessed to get to know some of the really good people up in your borough like taddy atlas and your borough president. they're doing great work. tell us how bad it is. we're looking at pictures of the people under water during the flood. i saw some of that stuff on your own island of staten island a couple weeks ago, it was really rough. >> it's horrendous. this is a war zone. let me be clear, don't forget about -- you see homes crushed. you see people's personal belongings wiped out to sea, but there's also emotional scars that you cannot see. just this past weekend i had a mother tell me her children are deathly afraid when it rains because they think there's going to be another flood. you know, those are the stories that you don't see every day in the news but the impact, they are devastated, they're emotionally a wreck, and that's also why we're fighting so hard to pass this package, to give them a little normalcy back in their lives.
2:42 pm
>> you know, i'll say you have one thing going for you, community spirit. i have never seen anything like it at st. charles church, the way those people held together and teddy atlas' operation. it was so inspiring to see people work so hard for each other. >> i have never been more proud of staten island. i have never been more proud of my constituency. teddy atlas is a friend. i have been in the boxing gym when i've been corrected. let me just say i'm very, very, very proud of staten island. they are resilient and they are tough but they do need our help. >> i agree. let's hope it works tonight. thank you congress mon michael grimm who represents staten island and other parts of new york. perhaps no one has been more vok ideal in his anger about the slow pace of federal said than new jersey governor chris christie. let's listen to the governor. >> new jersey does not expect anything more than what was done for louisiana and alabama and mississippi in katrina. what was done in joplin, missouri. what was done in the floods in iowa. we don't expect anything more
2:43 pm
than that, but we will not accept anything less. and if they want to make new rules about disasters, well, they picked the wrong state to make the new rules with. >> that's jersey talking. joining me now is new york congressman steve israel. congressman from new york who represents areas hard hit by superstorm sandy. steve, thank you so much, congressman, for coming on. >> sure, chris. >> you're a partisan democrat, fair enough. will you lats talk about this issue as a national thing. why new york, i thought they got great media coverage, when you have a baseball star in new york, they're national figures, just huge, but yet this time i do think that the media is undercut. i'm as guilty as anybody for not seeing what's right in front of our eyes and for some reason it hasn't gotten the pictures on tv as much as, you know, katrina did. i have learned on the ground what it's like. there's some pictures we're showing now and it ain't going away. this is a horror for many months, point pleasant, new jersey. this is going on and on for the people in these houses. >> well, look, i do not believe
2:44 pm
that this is anti-new york, chris. i believe that you now have a group of members of congress who are fairly new who are anti-government. they fundamentally and philosophically do not believe that when a disaster strikes, that is the obligation of the federal government to help. look, i'm dush. >> when does the federal government have an obligation to help? >> they don't believe the federal government ever has an obligation to help and this tea party caucus has become a real problem. my constituents are not interested in right or left, they're not interested in who is to blame. they just want to fixed. i think we're going to get this done. i'm cautiously optimistic. i'm optimistic because the democrats will put it over the top. we will provide the votes to put over the top. i'm cautious because just a couple hours ago on a modest bill supported boy the house republican leadership for $11 billion, nearly one-half of the republican caucus voted against even that. we need to put the politics aside and just get this done and do the right thing. >> tell us about the human aspect in your district. you know the people that come to you for help. what's it like up there in your district in new york? >> well, look, it was
2:45 pm
devastating, it continues to be very challenging, and my congress district, virtually my entire district looked like north korea. it was plunged into the darkness, no power, no lights, very, very difficult. in the coastal areas of moo i district, people were devastated. they lost everything. we're 80 days since the storm struck. i think we're an hour away from finally being able to say to those people, we've put the politics aside, we're doing the right thing. it's bad enough to be devastated by a weather storm. it's unacceptable to be devastated by a political storm. >> we're looking at pictures of breezy point in new york. it's unbelievable. >> breezy point -- i have never seen anything like it and i was in louisiana after katrina. i saw it. the difference was after katrina, everybody helped. for the reasons i just mentioned, after this storm, after superstorm sandy, it became a political debate. just not right. >> well, breezy point fund is a good organization. there's also in the rockaways organizations like st. francis desails church. on the ground there's some really, really good people doing
2:46 pm
some wonderful stuff but it's a macro problem. >> we need congress to be as good as those people have been tonight. >> well, that's the standard. thank you, sir. i'm thrilled at that standard because it's real. coming up, president obama, he's fighting and winning these political battles with all kinds of people, neoconservatives, gun people, debt crisys, all kinds of people. the weress is in a fighting mood if you haven't noticed and he's winning. come back in a moment for hale, the place for politics. [ all ] fort benning, georgia, in 1999. [ male announcer ] usaa auto insurance is often handed down from generation to generation because it offers a superior level of protection and because usaa's commitment to serve the military, veterans, and their families is without equal. begin your legacy. get an auto-insurance quote. usaa. we know what it means to serve.
2:47 pm
looks like you're in a pickle. yeah. can you get me out of it ? just so happens i know a chap... book any flight and hotel together and get access to our free personal concierge service. any need, any question, we're on call 24/7. [ male announcer ] shift the balance of power decisively in your favor. the exclusive 8-speed transmission and rotary shifter in the 2013 ram 1500. engineered to move heaven and earth. guts. glory. ram. the new ram 1500. motor trend's 2013 truck of the year.
2:48 pm
in 1981 ronald reagan took the oath of office in an economic turndown of course and called for an era of national renewal and he had this message for the role of government in american life and the country's new conservative tide. >> in this present crisis, government is not the solution to our problem. government is the problem. [ applause ] >> wow. later on in the inaugural luncheon, president reagan announced after four days in captivity the 52 americans held hostage in iran were on their way home. we'll be right back. [ male announcer ] you are a business pro. executor of efficiency.
2:49 pm
you can spot an amateur from a mile away... while going shoeless and metal-free in seconds. and from national. because only national lets you choose any car in the aisle...and go. you can even take a full-size or above, and still pay the mid-size price. now this...will work. [ male announcer ] just like you, business pro. just like you. go national. go like a pro. how did i know? well, i didn't really. see, i figured low testosterone would decrease my sex drive... but when i started losing energy and became moody... that's when i had an honest conversation with my doctor. we discussed all the symptoms... then he gave me some blood tests. showed it was low t. that's it. it was a number -- not just me. [ male announcer ] today, men with low t have androgel 1.62% (testosterone gel). the #1 prescribed topical testosterone replacement therapy, increases testosterone when used daily. women and children should avoid contact with application sites.
2:50 pm
discontinue androgel and call your doctor if you see unexpected signs of early puberty in a child, or signs in a woman, which may include changes in body hair or a large increase in acne, possibly due to accidental exposure. men with breast cancer or who have or might have prostate cancer, and women who are or may become pregnant or are breastfeeding, should not use androgel. serious side effects include worsening of an enlarged prostate, possible increased risk of prostate cancer, lower sperm count, swelling of ankles, feet, or body, enlarged or painful breasts, problems breathing during sleep, and blood clots in the legs. tell your doctor about your medical conditions and medications, especially insulin, corticosteroids, or medicines to decrease blood clotting. so...what do men do when a number's too low? turn it up! [ male announcer ] in a clinical study, over 80% of treated men had their t levels restored to normal. talk to your doctor about all your symptoms. get the blood tests. change your number. turn it up. androgel 1.62%.
2:51 pm
we're back. remember make my remember make my day? that is the thought of the president and his administration right now. gun safety, cabinet posts, the debt ceiling. it's looking like they're finding success. is this is a preview of a winning second obama presidential term? nia-malika henderson and glen thrush. nia, i've missed you. i've seen you on other shows. i've seen some sightings. but thank you for coming back. i find from the producers you have theories about the president. in his first press conference -- the last one of the old year the president warned republicans not to play politics when it comes to the debt ceiling. here's the president. >> but they will not collect ransom in exchange for not crashing the american economy.
2:52 pm
the financial well being of the american people is not leverage to be used. the full faith and credit of the united states of america is not a bargaining chip. >> and that's yesterday's last press conference of the presidential term. newt gingrich of all people reacted by saying the president was bullying republicans. that's a long way from saying he's weak. now he's a bully. let's watch. >> i don't think we should pick fights where we are in a position that we can't, in fact, in the end enforce our will. we have no evidence that barack obama's going to compromise. i think this president is deliberately seeking confrontation and is going out of his way to bully house republicans. >> we'll see. winston churchill once said when people like newt hung around in politics after they were defeated, we more disappearages. i wonder my thought about this guy. why he's still on television. anyway, newt gingrich said the president's a bully.
2:53 pm
yours? >> very different from what people said before about this president which is he would fold early in these negotiations. settle for a half a loaf rather than going for the whole loaf. he is basically continuing a campaign. he is going to the american people and using the bully pulpit much more effectively than he ever has. using all the levers within his office. considering executive action around gun control and also going to vice president biden. kind of an inside game there. also going to the outside game. and looking at public opinion. and he's finding out what the public wants trying to lead the public opinion parade but also be in the middle of it. >> let me check you on that. the assault weapon ban tomorrow? >> i think so. >> let me go to this other we of the -- of sticking with hagel. glen, i was impressed. i thought after awhile around
2:54 pm
christmastime i was thinking hagel was cooked. that the anti-gay comment he made and the anti-israeli -- it's not really anti-israeli, but bag language. it could strike the wrong cords. but he's in. it looks like he's got a nice shot at the nomination being confirmed. . >> obviously he came out today which was a big deal for the white house. this is the rule of the schoolyard. obama sees himself as being in a brawl with these guys up on the hill. one of the reasons he's stuck with hagel is he ditched susan rice. there was a sense you couldn't pull the plug on two consecutive nominees. that doesn't mean he was backing hagel once to begin with. but once the name was floated out there, it would look bad if he pulled the plog plug on him. >> is that reporting or is that -- >> that's reporting. >> good for you. the president was sort of
2:55 pm
preparing the battlefield. if there's a failure to pay bills, don't look at both sides. none of the malarkey and cliches. will that work its way into news coverage? will people begin to buy the president's shaping of the battlefield? >> well, it seems like that has happened every time. that republicans get more of the blame when we have these sorts of, you know, end of the night deals that have to get made. because they have been doing a bit of foot dragging. so he definitely is laying down the rhetoric. i think one of the things he said in that process conference which i think people will resonate with which is this idea if you go out and buy an expensive meal, you can't when the check comes refuse to pay the bill. he a likening that to a refusal
2:56 pm
to raise the debt ceiling. it resonates to people who can understand the debate in their own language in some ways. >> glenn, do you think the people in the tea party are paying the bill or not paying the bill or saying yes to spending? the way they look at it. >> i think what they think is they're looking at a different set of polls that say a significant portion of the electorate cares about deficit reduction. the problem is none of those polls are taken in isolation. i think nia is completely right. the obama people have continued polling, polling, polling, polling. and they feel they've got the public on their side. and their choice of words. for instance, the president talked about education. education polls well amongst women. they know what they're doing when they play the outside game. >> well said. thank you so much nia-malika henderson, welcome back to "hardball." and glenn thrush. remember them chasing the
2:57 pm
revenuers out of town? you're watching "hardball," the place for politics. aww man. [ male announcer ] returns are easy with free pickup from the u.s. postal service. we'll even drop off boxes if you need them. visit pay, print, and have it picked up for free. any time of year. ♪ nice sweater. thank you. ♪
2:58 pm
2:59 pm
disc Borrow a DVD of this show
info Stream Only
Uploaded by
TV Archive
on 1/15/2013